Guides
Holiday Gift Cards: How to Set Up a Program That Pays Off
Gift cards are one of the easiest ways for a small shop to earn more over the holidays. This guide shows US retailers how to set up a gift card program: choosing card types and amounts, writing clear terms that follow federal and state rules, selling more at the register, tracking what you owe on unused cards and the mistakes to avoid.
Every December, someone walks into your shop looking for a present for a person they don't know well: a coworker, a teacher, a nephew who's "hard to buy for." If you don't sell gift cards, that customer leaves empty-handed. If you do, you make a sale in thirty seconds and bring a new customer through your door in January.
Gift cards are one of the simplest ways for a small shop to earn more over the holidays. But a program that's thrown together in a rush can create problems later, from balances nobody can track to cards that break state rules.
The short answer: choose physical cards, digital cards or both, set clear terms that follow federal and state law, display them where people can't miss them at the counter, and track every card in your POS so you always know how much you owe in unused balances.
Why gift cards pay off for small shops
You get paid upfront. The money comes in when the card is sold, often weeks before it's spent. In a slow January, that cash already sitting in your account helps.
They bring in new customers. The person who receives the card may never have visited your shop. A gift card is a free introduction, and if they like what they find, they come back.
People often spend more than the card. When someone comes in with a $50 card, they rarely buy exactly $50 worth. Many will pick something a little more expensive and pay the difference.
They fill the post-holiday dip. Cards given in December get spent in January and February, when foot traffic usually slows down.
They're easy last-minute sales. For the shopper who's run out of time or ideas, a gift card at the register is an easy yes.
Setting up your gift card program
1. Choose your card type.
- Physical cards: plastic or printed cards with a barcode or card number. They feel like a real present and look good in a holiday card or stocking.
- Digital cards: sent by email or text. They're perfect for last-minute and out-of-town shoppers.
- Both: many shops offer physical cards in store and digital cards for people who can't make it in.
Whichever you choose, every card needs a unique number that your POS can look up, so you can check and update the balance at the register.
2. Decide on amounts. Offer a few set amounts ($25, $50 and $100 are common) plus a custom amount. Fixed amounts make the decision easy for shoppers. Custom amounts help when someone has a specific budget.
3. Write clear terms. Keep them short and print them on the card or the card holder. Cover:
- Where the card can be used (one store or all your locations)
- Whether it can be used online
- How to check the balance
- Whether it can be reloaded
- What happens if it's lost or stolen
- Any expiration date or fees, if your state allows them
4. Follow federal and state gift card rules. Under the federal Credit CARD Act, store gift cards generally can't expire within five years of the date they were issued or last loaded. Inactivity fees are only allowed after at least 12 months without use, no more than one per month, and only if they're clearly disclosed (FindLaw). Many states go further, and some don't allow expiration dates or fees at all. Unused balances may also fall under your state's unclaimed property rules after a number of years.
The simplest approach for most small shops is no expiration date and no fees. It's easier to explain, it keeps you on the right side of the rules in most states, and customers like it. Check your own state's rules, or ask your accountant or attorney, before you print anything.
This section is general information, not legal advice.
5. Decide who can sell and redeem cards. Give staff the permission to sell and redeem cards, but limit who can change balances, cancel cards or issue replacement cards. This protects you from mistakes and misuse.
6. Test it before the rush. Sell a test card, check the balance, use part of it, then use the rest. Make sure the receipt shows the remaining balance.
How to sell more gift cards over the holidays
Put them where people pay. A small display right by the register is the most effective spot. Add a simple sign: "Not sure what to get? Give a gift card."
Train staff to mention them. When a customer can't decide or says they're shopping for someone else, a quick "We also have gift cards" turns hesitation into a sale.
Make them look like a gift. Offer a nice envelope, small box or card holder. People pay more happily for a gift card that looks good under the tree.
Run a simple bonus offer. "Buy a $50 gift card, get a $10 bonus card" is a classic for a reason. Set the bonus card to be used in January or February, so it brings people back during a slower month. Check how bonus cards are treated under your state's rules, since they're often handled differently from paid gift cards.
Promote them in the last week. In the final days before Christmas, push gift cards on your social media, in your email newsletter and on your shop door. Last-minute shoppers are actively looking for an easy answer.
Sell them for businesses. Local companies often buy gift cards for staff or clients. A quick note to nearby offices or your business customers can lead to a bulk order.
Think beyond December. Gift cards also sell well for Valentine's Day, Mother's Day, Father's Day, graduations and teacher appreciation. Keep them on display all year.
Tracking gift cards and the money you owe
This is the part many shops get wrong.
A gift card sale isn't income yet. When you sell a $50 card, you've taken $50, but you still owe the customer $50 worth of goods. In accounting terms, it's a liability until the card is used. Only when the card is redeemed does it become a sale. Ask your accountant how to record gift card sales and redemptions for your business.
Keep a running total of what's outstanding. You should always be able to see how much money is sitting on unused gift cards. A good POS shows this as a gift card liability report, so you're not caught out when a wave of cards gets used in January.
Track every card individually. Each card should have its own number and history: when it was sold, how much was loaded, and every time it was used. This makes it easy to answer a customer's balance question and to spot anything unusual.
Mistakes to avoid
- Selling cards that aren't tracked in your POS. Paper certificates in a drawer are easy to lose and hard to check.
- Counting gift card sales as revenue. It makes December look better than it was and can cause tax surprises.
- Confusing expiry or fee rules. If customers feel tricked, the goodwill a gift card creates is gone.
- Letting anyone change balances. Limit that permission to managers.
- Running out of physical cards. Order more stock than you think you need in early November.
- Forgetting about cards you've already sold. If you switch POS systems, move every open balance across before you go live.
Your gift card setup checklist
- Choose physical cards, digital cards or both
- Order enough physical cards and holders for the season
- Set your standard amounts and allow a custom amount
- Write short, clear terms and print them on the card or holder
- Check federal and state rules on expiry dates and fees
- Set staff permissions for selling, redeeming and adjusting cards
- Test a full sale, partial use and final use
- Set up a display and sign by the register
- Plan a bonus offer for January or February
- Schedule gift card reminders for the last week before Christmas
- Make sure you can see your total gift card liability
How SimplyPOS helps
SimplyPOS includes a gift card program on the SimplyRetail plan, so cards, sales and reports stay in one place.
- Issue and look up cards at the register, with balances updated on every sale
- Staff permissions to control who can issue and manage cards
- Expiry options you can set to match your own policy
- A liability report that shows how much is outstanding on unused cards
- SimplyRewards points to keep regular customers coming back after the holidays
- Data migration to bring existing customer records across when you switch
See gift cards and rewards for the details.
Frequently asked questions
Are gift cards worth it for a small business?
For most retail shops, yes. You get paid upfront, the person who receives the card is often a new customer, and many people spend more than the card's value when they come in.
Can small business gift cards expire?
Under federal law, store gift cards generally can't expire within five years of being issued or last loaded, and some states don't allow expiration dates at all. Check your state's rules before you set any expiry.
Should I offer physical or digital gift cards?
Both work well. Physical cards make a nicer present and sell well at the register, while digital cards suit last-minute and out-of-town shoppers.
How do I account for gift card sales?
A gift card sale is usually recorded as money you owe until the card is used, then as a sale when it's redeemed. Your accountant can confirm the right way to record it for your business.
What's a good holiday gift card promotion?
A bonus card offer, such as a $10 bonus card with every $50 gift card, works well when the bonus is valid in January or February. It brings customers back during a quieter month.
Get your gift cards ready for the holidays
Open the SimplyPOS web app to set up your gift card program before the rush. You can start on the free plan and move to SimplyRetail when you're ready to sell gift cards.
Open the web app | See gift cards and rewards
Getting the rest of your stock ready? Read our holiday inventory prep checklist.